Michael V. Cibella, LLC - Litigation Attorney
Criminal Defense Attorney | Civil Litigation
Free Initial Consultation 212-818-1880 Available 24/7


  • Michael saved my life. There is no other way to put it . . . Thank you, Michael, for giving me a new day! Assault in the First Degree in Manhattan, August 2016
  • I have a clean record and I will always have Michael to thank for that. Aggravated DWI with an accident in Brooklyn, February 2016
  • Michael was invaluable in helping me through a difficult time. After being arrested with a DWI and losing my job shortly after, I was at my wit's end. DWI with an Accident and Leaving the Scene, January 2016
  • Because of you, I'm driving my kids to school! Thank you!! DWI & DMV Refusal Hearing, August 2015
  • Mike Cibella did an excellent job! . . . When something wasn’t right the day the charge was to be dismissed, Mike hunted down the DA to make it right and end the case with a dismissal. We are grateful to have engaged him. Criminal Mischief, July 2015
  • Michael, I am grateful for your help with the DA and can't thank you enough for what you did for our son. You gave him a second chance . . . Grand Larceny, May 2015
  • Michael could not have done more for me in immediately being available and putting me at ease . . . had a bull-dog-like tenacity that never stopped fighting for my case and had a great court presentation. DWI, March 2015
  • I know a dodged a bullet and it's all thanks to Michael's judgment, experience and hard work! Insurance Fraud, September 2014
  • ... Again, I'm forever grateful. I wish there were better words. THANK YOU! Fraud Investigation, July 2014
  • Thank you for all your hard work and for making this crazy process a little easier to handle. I'm very fortunate to have had you on my side. DWI, February 2014
  • Thank you very much for all that you've done. You made this difficult process very easy for me and I'm doing much better thanks to your help. DWI, December 2013
  • Thank you for saving my career! Investment Bank Trader, Larceny case, July 2011.
Michael V. Cibella Michael V. Cibella
Practice Areas

Is Fitbit data fit for murder case as valid evidence?

Is Fitbit data fit for murder case as valid evidence?

As time passes, society’s everyday norms change. Specifically, technology and how we all rely on technology changes. Many New Yorkers rely on laptops, iPads, cellphones and their watches as routine parts of their lives. A current out-of-state case highlights how technological advancements not only leak into our lives, but into criminal cases, too.

New York Daily News reports a husband who is charged with the murder of his wife faces a new source of supposed evidence to combat. According to investigators, data collected from the homicide victim’s Fitbit suggests the husband’s been dishonest regarding the timeline leading up to the incident. How threatening is this kind of data in criminal cases?

A central aspect of criminal cases is for parties to create a timeline related to the incident. A defendant will work with his trusted defense lawyer to put together the details of the time and events surrounding, in this case, the death of someone. In this case, investigators claim that the victim’s Fitbit data shows she was alive and moving after her husband claims she was allegedly murdered by an intruder.

This alleged evidence creates doubt about the defendant and his honesty. It can be dangerous, therefore, to his chances in court. But dangerous doesn’t mean the defendant’s murder case is hopeless. This is where the aggressive and informed defense of a legal team becomes invaluable.

It is not as though Fitbit data alone paints a certain picture of the defendant as guilty. Most people who use a Fitbit understand the device is not always accurate. Someone’s measured heart rate can be off, and steps are sometimes miscalculated. Simply put, it could be controversial to and sloppy to convict someone of a crime based on a step tracker alone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Criminal Defense Attorney